A Question of Truth - is there truth in the Bible?

So: What IS it all about?

To understand what the scriptures we have mean we must examine Genesis again in the light of what we have discovered in this search that has lasted with intensity of hours a day over the last three years.

Until the creation of the nation of Israel the peoples were searching for a way to eternal life. This, it seems from recent research, was usually through the stars as giving access to a place in the heavens where souls lived for ever.

There was, as far as we know, little idea or worship of one eternal creator God. Certainly there was no relationship with such a being as a loving father.

We have seen that scholars believe there was more than one writer and someone later put the writings together with some connecting remarks to give continuity.

Applying this to Genesis, and remembering that these scriptures were written for Israel to read and be thereby educated over a number of centuries, more comes to light.

There are different periods in the history of the nation, which have to be addressed.

The first is when they left Egypt and were a rabble (Ex. 12 v 37 &38) only used to Egyptian ways and laws. After four generations they would be beginning to loose their heritage from the patriarchs. Strong leadership, guidance, and a sense of nationhood and purpose would be necessary. They needed to know their roots and God's promises for them. They must become united. Laws and festivals bound them together.

Later they needed to be a nation of warriors, not slaves, or nomads, to take the land.

Then they needed to know how to live in it in a just society that could stand proud amongst the nations. Again laws and festivals of remembrance of how God had led them would do this.

They were to be different - a peculiar people: special for their God Yahweh. They would sometimes be called a son and sometimes a wife of the Lord Yahweh.

As Moses led them from Egypt there was still much of that culture with them. This would take a long time to shed completely. Some things had to go immediately, such as worshipping other gods and having graven images. As they worshipped the creator God they were not to eat blood as this signified the life of the animal which belonged to its creator.

On entry into the land Joshua reminded them of the laws of Moses, and the blessings for keeping them and worshipping only Yahweh, God of Israel, and the curses that would come upon them if they turned away from Him. It is interesting that in the last chapter of Joshua he asks them to turn from the gods their forefathers worshipped over the river (Aram and Sumer) and in Egypt. He asked them to get rid of the gods still among them. So even after the time in the desert this new generation still were carrying these gods forbidden in the law of Moses! They promised to follow only Yahweh from then on and Joshua wrote this down and set up stones to witness to this.

When Jesus was entering Jerusalem and being greeted by his disciples he said that if they did not cry out to God in this way the very stones would. Was he reminding them of the promise to follow the pure Mosaic law?The beginning of the book of Judges shows this was soon forgotten. (See Judges chapter 2). As they turned away to worship the gods of the tribes already in the land, and did not eliminate them as they had been told, disasters came upon them, as they had also been told it would. They were invaded time and time again.Still they did not learn, and even after the temple was built they were again worshipping other gods. This was an abomination to the Lord Yahweh, who found their sacrifices and celebrations to Him meaningless whilst they also worshipped other gods. They were like an unfaithful wife. This is the theme of all the prophets who constantly called for a return to the pure worship of Yahweh alone.This is seen in Isaiah ch.1, Jeremiah ch.2, Ezekiel ch.8, (where idolatry is actually happening in the temple itself!), Daniel's prayer in ch.9, the book of Hosea, especially ch. 2 & 4), Micah ch. 1&6, Zephaniah ch. 1, and Malachi ch. 2, as examples.This is theme of the old testament.

Therefore, no matter who wrote Genesis, be it Moses or others, the point being made must be the same : this nation as it is formed must learn that Yahweh is its One and Only God. They are not to worship the sun, the moon, or stars, or graven images of anything. Their God is invisible. He is the Creator. He made everything and has given them their wealth and their land and made them a people to worship and give thanks to Him. They are to look only to Him for their needs and guidance.

If we bring what we have learned that is on this site about the beliefs of the ancient peoples, especially Egypt, to the stories in Genesis we can see that the same points are being made there.

The emphasis on this being about the formation of the nation of Israel is shown as early as the story of the flood. Here we have the escape of Noah and his sons because Noah was a man righteous in his generation (Gen. 6-10). Japheth was the eldest (ch.10 v 21), but the order they are always listed is Shem, Ham and Japheth.

Shem, meaning "name" is the father of all the Semitic peoples, including the Arameans, and the people of Uz, where Job lived, and the Eber (Hebrews) who produced the Israelites from Abraham and Isaac, the Ishmaelites (from Abraham and Hagar), the Midianites (from Abraham and Keturah), and the Edomites (from Esau brother of Jacob), from whom came the Amelekites who were enemies of the Israelites.

These would, then, all be the people of "the Name". Which interesting as they are those who follow either Judaism or Islam today in the Middle East. Jordan, for instance, is called the Hashemite kingdom.

Ham was the father of the Canaanite tribes in the land promised to Abraham, and the Mizraim father of the Egyptians and the Philistines.

Japheth was the father of all the Europeans.

Going further back to the creation there are clearly two stories being told in Genesis chapters one to three. The first is a general one about the creation of the universe, the earth and all that is in them. In this God is called Elohim, which is the pleural form of El, which means a god. Whether you think this means there were multiple gods involved, as in so in many creation stories from round the world, or whether it means one supreme God with multiple attributes, is for you to decide. But for those for whom this book was written; i.e. the Israelites (and those who practise Judaism today), there was only One God. This is the story of creation that the forefathers had handed down to Israel of how everything came into being.

The text then begins with another story of how a particular man and woman were made by a God called Yahweh. The man is taken from the ground and life breathed into him and he is called "Adam" which sounds like Hebrew for "ground". The woman is taken from the man and becomes the mother of all the living - she is called" Eve", which sounds like the Hebrew for "living"

They are placed in the garden of pleasure-"Eden" which has been prepared by Yahweh. Here they have the choice between eating of the tree of life, or the tree of the knowledge of good and bad. They make the wrong choice in eating of the tree of the knowledge of good and bad, and so face death and are exiled from the garden to the ground from which they were taken.

If Adam is Abraham being taken from the ground (actually the "dust" which could mean death) to the east of Mesopotamia and brought to Canaan, which was the beautiful land promised to him; then Eve is Israel who comes from him and are the people who have life. She is like his sister wife Sarah, who also a part of him as a close relative. Eve is taken from Adam's side whilst he is in a deep sleep. This is an adaptation of the "lady of the rib" story from Sumer.

Abraham was in a deep sleep when in the land to the east and before the nation came to birth - he had no idea that God was preparing to give him a land. He was also in a deep sleep in Gen. 12 when God made the covenant with him to give him the land in which the nation of Israel would live. So there is a strong connection with the land and the people. The covenant of circumcision was about being in the people and is given later just before Isaac is born.

The story is to warn them that choosing the forbidden fruit of turning to other gods and religions instead of trusting in the God who formed them as a people, will mean exile from the land and death.

The serpent coiled and with its tail in its mouth represented to other religions the cycle of death and rebirth - i.e. their eternal life. The serpent, or dragon in the sky, and the path of the milky way (like the Nile) and the eternal movements of the star formations signified eternity to them and to reach them was to become a god..

Also the tree of Asherah was the bearer of fruit that ensured you would have eternal life, as had the goddess Asherah herself.

The story makes it plain that to become gods as the serpent says is the way of death, not life. The serpent is cursed to crawl in the dust of death as the result of its seduction of the people of the God Yahweh..

When Israel was made a nation on leaving Egypt they were to forget all the other gods and religions and worship only Yahweh. Eve says the serpent made her forget what God had said. Israel did forget and worship other gods, and as Moses warned would happen they were exiled.

In Genesis three they hid themselves from God in their naked vulnerability after forgetting and making the decision to eat of the forbidden fruit of other religions.

Israel became vulnerable when they did that and their enemies were allowed to overcome them as they were no longer under the protection of God.

There was always enmity between the worshippers of Yahweh and those who worshiped the serpent and all it represents.

Israel will have pain in giving birth to her children and the children of Abraham will toil hard for little return if they do not worship only Yahweh. Compare this with the blessings and cursings in Deuteronomy 27 & 28.Moving on through Genesis to the story of Cain and Abel and the birth of Seth, from whom the line of the chosen people comes, we can see the emphasis on what is relevant to Israel later.The name Cain can mean "brought forth" or "jealousy". He is the first to be brought forth from the union of Adam and Eve, but he is jealous of his younger brother Abel when his offering of the fruit of the ground is rejected in favour of the animal sacrifice from Abel. It seems Abel's offering of a first born of his flocks was what God required. This was what was required of Israel, too, as a nation. Is this the beginning of the laws to come, or the reinforcing of laws they already had? The covering of skins given by God to Adam and Eve meant an animal had to be sacrificed. So Abel had understood and acted upon it, but Cain had not so responded. Being right, however, did not, in this case, save Abel from being murdered by his brother. The first murder in scripture is because of religious jealousy - a warning! Cain pays the penalty of being exiled from the land.Cain is told that he could have done the right thing: a sin offering crouches at his door and its desire is towards him, and he should have taken it. This is a different rendering from the usual of these verses, but see the study on Genesis on this site for the Hebrew background; which supports this.Cain is doomed to wander outside the land, but is protected by God.It is not through his offspring that Israel comes, but from Seth, his younger brother, who is the son in the likeness of his father.There are parallels later in scripture of younger brothers being the chosen for inheritance rather than the eldest.

The story of the flood has also been taken and adapted to make points in line with Israelite religion.

The ancients believed disasters came because the gods were angry; and so a flood must happen because the people had been wicked. This is in Sumerian texts much older than the Bible account.

Only the righteous survive. As shown on "Other creation stories from round the world" the creation and flood stories are world wide.

If you look at the text we have there are two accounts interwoven. The passages using "God" and those using "Yahweh" can be separated out and each will give a very similar story.

The name of the hero is Noah meaning "rest" or "comfort" from the painful toil due to the ground cursed by God.

After the flood has receded Noah gives thanks to God and builds an altar to the Yahweh and makes a sacrifice of clean animals. How did he know which were clean and unclean? This information was supposed to be given later at Sinai.

After this God promises not to curse the ground again because of the evil of men. But the word for curse used here is not the same as that used in chapters 3 and 4 of Genesis. In chapters 3 and 4 the word is "aror" which means to be detestable, and in chapter 9 it is "lekalel" which means to "despise" or disesteem, as Young has it.

So comfort comes from Noah, who was a righteous man and gave the right sacrifices to God - Yahweh.

So we have progressed from animal sacrifice to the right kind of animal sacrifice. This kind of sacrifice by a righteous person avails for them and for others. The covenant in chapter nine made with Noah

, is announced by God, not Yahweh. This seems to be for all man kind, but the statement about not cursing (despising) the ground again is spoken by Yahweh to Noah, after his sacrifice.(see end ch.8).

Job, who was a Semite from Uz, also sacrificed to God. He seems to have lived in ancient times as a patriarch. He and his friends do not speak of God as Yahweh, but the narrator does (which suggests the story itself has been imported from an older source). At the end of the book as the friends sacrifice and Job prays for them he is rewarded by being reinstated with wealth and family again - only doubly so. The book teaches that one should worship God no matter what happens, and after this testing you will be rewarded.So there were stories from the ancient world about man's relationship with a God, to whom sacrifices were made, but that for Israel it was to be only clean animals and only for the God Yahweh.In ch. 10 it is Yahweh God of Shem, and may God enlarge Japheth, and he will live in the tents of Shem i.e. under his covering.

When we get to the account of Abraham again there is use of both "God" and "Yahweh". Hagar, the Egyptian mother of Ishmael, refers to Yahweh. It is God who makes the covenant of circumcision with Abraham, and makes the promises for Ishmael. Also it is God who seems to send Abraham to sacrifice his son, but Yahweh who provides the alternative sacrifice!

In the story of Jacob's life it is mostly "God". Leah speaks often of Yahweh, but Rachel does not.

It is not until Moses' encounter on Sinai that the name of Yahweh is used frequently again.

Where we have Moses speaking to the people it is often "Yahweh your God". In fact, in Deuteronomy, as many times as there are verses this phrase appears.

In Genesis chapter one it was "God", and in chapter two it was "Yahweh God". Then it became just "Yahweh". So there is the God who is Creator of everything and so is God of everyone, and there is the God called Yahweh, who is the God of Israel.

There seems to be a progression from an impersonal God, who was the Creator, to a personal God called Yahweh, who was the God of Israel. But we know that the Sumerians had the idea of a personal god for each person. For Israel he is a national God for all the people descended from Abraham and Sarah, and Isaac, and Jacob. The descendants of Ishmael, son of Abraham and Hagar the Egyptian and the descendants of Abraham and Keturah (including the Midianites), are also in the covenant of circumcision, which about belonging to the people of God. The covenant concerning the land made later was only for the descendants of Abraham through Sarah: Isaac and Jacob.(it did not include Jacob's twin brother, Esau).So the progression is also towards a separating out of a "peculiar" people.The account of the creation of the universe and all in it is also about separating.What happened at the time of the Exodus and the forming of the nation was a separating of Israel from Egypt demonstrated before hand in the distinction made between hem during the plagues.In the passages where both terms are used, the "Yahweh" verses seem to speak of a person who acts very much like a human being and so is what is called "anthropomorphic"(In the book of Joshua the same pattern as with Moses is seen. Yahweh speaks to Joshua, and Joshua says to the people " Yahweh your God").If Moses had written all the first five books of the Bible, the question has to be asked: why was he not consistent with the name used for God? It would be expected that he might use "God" up until his encounter at Sinai, and then use the Name revealed to him there from then on.

The history of the formation of the nation of Israel and the taking of the land promised to them written in these books shows a progression of understanding of the relationship the Israelites had with their God.

Abraham leaves the land and goes down to Egypt to escape a famine and returns with great wealth. Jacob leaves the land to escape his brothers anger and goes to the land of his fore fathers and returns with great wealth and a large family. His whole family leaves the land to escape a famine and goes down to Egypt and returns with great wealth and vastly increased numbers.

This pattern reinforces the promises to Abraham and reassures Israel that if they leave the land because of adversity they will return richer and more numerous.

This must have been a comfort to those going into exile later.

It now seems obvious that all the stories in Genesis have been compiled from historical accounts about real people, but have been told in such a way as to make particular points about the land and people of Israel and their relationship with their God, Yahweh.

They have been put together at a later date than it might seem at first glance, gathering information from different sources. They have then, been edited with a particular agenda in mind. They cannot be unbiased in that case.

They tell a spiritual story from the view of Israel and her God.

Christians ignore this at their peril.


next section : Is the Bible the Word of God?



visit my new minisite : the silent music of the mirror